MysteryNet Home
Mysteries
Greats
TV Movies
Books
Community
July 3
Hardback • PaperbackPrevious Reviews
 
In Her Defense Midnight Come Again
by Dana Stabenow
DiscussionOther BooksBuy Online

Reviewed by Ted Fitzgerald

Just as American business has gotten used to the ISO 9000 international quality standard, crime fiction readers are now grappling with acceptance of a new storytelling standard, ISO 2000, ISO in this case standing for Icing of Significant Others. Indeed, it seems as if in the last two years or so, more crime solvers' sweethearts have picked up their room key from St. Pete than mobsters were mowed down in the St. Valentine's Day Massacre. And Alaska's Kate Shugak is no exception. Last seen clutching her lover's body at the end of Hunter's Moon, Kate is nowhere to be found as Midnight Come Again opens.
Searching for the Inuit detective is Jim Chopin, the state trooper and ladies man known as Chopper Jim. His frustrating hunt is interrupted by an undercover assignment that takes him to Bering, a busy fishing town on the Kuskokwim River in southwestern Alaska, where he's expected to help the Feds identify and capture a ruthless Russian mobster who's intending to smuggle nuclear material in through the U.S.'s northernmost back door. His first surprise (and the first of many coincidences in this book) is his co-worker at the air freight service that's his cover. She's none other than the missing Kate, shorn of her real name and much of her hair, seeking refuge from memories, sorrow and any real feeling through endless hours of hard labor. The meeting sets off sparks of anger and conflicting emotions and leads to complications, personal and professional. The mixed results of Jim's sleuthing come to involve Kate in the case and become the catalyst for her gradual and painful reentry into the world of the living.
Midnight Come Again is rich in detail and character. Dana Stabenow's portrait of Bering in its busiest season, her implicit nod to the vital link air travel plays in the 49th state, her observations about politics, native culture, business and human nature are interesting and instructive. Her characterizations, including Kate's relationship with her old college roommate, Alice, Alice's striving daughter Stephanie, and Alice's grandfather, who, it turns out, knew Kate's Emaa, very well, and, in particular, her angry, passionate and sometimes humorous sparring with
Do you enjoy stories set in the remote areas of Alaska? Are you interested in other native American cultures such as the Inuit? Do you enjoy books about Russian gangsters?

Join the discussion on:
Cold Climate Mysteries  >>
Jim (whose book this is almost as much as it is Kate's) are compassionate, warm and involving. Indeed, an unspoken subtext of the novel is how personal relationships are as vital to survival as air transportation, food and shelter in the wide range and vast solitude of Alaska.
The weak spot in Midnight is the mystery plot, which tends to mosey along and which relies heavily on coincidence, people being in the right place at the right time, and even a swift and timely recovery from temporary amnesia. There's not much wrong with using these conventions, providing they are sufficiently obscured so that the reader doesn't spot them right away. Which is not the case here. It's as if Stabenow framed the walls and put in the wiring but neglected to hang the sheetrock.


 

Discussion
 
Other Books
 
Buy Online

 


The Drood Review of Mystery features reviews of current mysteries, along with comprehensive guides to new titles. A six-issue (one year) subscription is $17 in the US, $21 in Canada and $27 overseas. For a limited time, mention MysteryNet and receive a seventh issue free! Make your check payable and send it to:
 
The Drood Review
306 South Main Suite 1C-107
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104